1940
Wollam Insurance Group is opened in Cortland to serve residents in the northern end of Trumbull County.
1963
Gene Salvasi founded the Mayflower Agencies - a conglomeration of several insurance agencies in North Jackson to serve the Mahoning County.
1970s
Ausmer Tuttle purchased the Wollam Insurance Group.
1987
Dan Wells purchased the Mayflower Agencies.
1990s
Wollam Insurance Group is sold to William Tuttle.
1996
Anderson, Cully and Cessna, Inc. was acquired by Mayflower Agencies.
2004
Baker Insurance Agency in Lake Milton was purchased.
Late 2004
John Palmer purchased the Mayflower Insurance Group.
2008
Mayflower Wollam Insurance Group is created through the merger of Mayflower Insurance Group and Wollam Insurance Group.
2009
Mayflower Wollam Insurance Group opened an office in Newton Falls.
2011
John Palmer became the sole owner of Mayflower Wollam Insurance Group.
2013
Mayflower Wollam acquired the Jerry Pasko & Associates Insurance Agency located in Poland, OH.