COVID-19 Updates

Mayflower Wollam Insurance Group has made some additional temporary changes and decisions in response to COVID-19.

As of November 30, 2020; our offices will be open for payments from 9:00 AM until 4:00 PM. The lobbies at our North Jackson and Cortland offices are open but are limited to one person at a time to ensure social distancing. We are still available to meet your needs via phone and email. All office phone numbers are open to process quote requests, policy changes or answer your coverage questions. We are also available via email at

You can also find your agent’s direct email in the “Team Bios” section under “About Us”.

**Policy changes cannot be bound through email.**

Payments will need to be made directly through your insurance company or by mailing your payment to one of our three offices.

Please reference the list of insurance company phone numbers below to make a payment over the phone.

American Modern: 800-543-2644

American Strategic: 866-274-8765

Auto-Owners: 800-232-2886

Cincinnati: 877-942-2455

Foremost: 800-527-3905

Hastings Mutual: 800-442-8277

Ohio Casualty: 800-843-6446

Ohio Fair Plan: 800-282-1772

Progressive: 877-776-2436

Safeco: 877-566-6001

Sandy & Beaver: 800-421-4693

Travelers: 877-878-2468

Westfield: 800-243-0210

Western Reserve Group: 800-362-0426

If your company number isn’t listed, please email

Mayflower Wollam Insurance Group is still committed to providing continuous service while maintaining our clients’ and employees’ health.

Thank you for your continued understanding and patience during this time.